RonRosenbaum.com: "A Short Course in Intellectual Self-Defense"

Sun

Mon

Tue

Wed

Thu

Fri

Sat

book cover
BUY The Shakespeare Wars, Random House, September 2006

Electrifying. A spectacular book. —Cynthia Ozick

…a thrilling personal confrontation…The Shakespeare Wars comes to us in waves of new revelations —Billy Collins, former U.S. poet laureate

Acclaimed journalist Ron Rosenbaum wrestles with the weightiest issues of Shakespeare studies in a down-to-earth manner that readers will applaud. —Publisher’s Weekly

Cultural journalism of the highest order. —Kirkus Reviews

Timely not least for the economy and clarity with which he outlines the casus belli…with Rosenbaum’s dispatches we now have a better sense of what the fuss is about. —John Sutherland, The Financial Times

book cover
BUY Explaining Hitler

A remarkable journey by one of the most original journalists and writers of our time. —David Remnick

A work of importance and fascination. —George Steiner, the [U.K.] Observer

A provacative work of cultural history that is as compelling as it is thoughtful, as readable as it is smart..Mr. Rosenbaum has made an important contribution to our understanding not just of Hitler, but of the cultural processes by which we try to come to terms with history as well… He has written an exciting, lucid book. —Michiko Kakutani, The New York Times

Intriguing, thought provoking and intelligent. —Ian Kershaw in The Guardian [U.k.]

Brilliant…restlessly probing and deeply intelligent. —Lance Morrow, Time

In Explaining Hitler, profound historical questions spring urgently and hauntingly to life. —Sam Tanenhaus

Cultural criticism served up as riveting narrative history —Marc Fisher The Washington Post

book cover
BUY The Secret Parts of Fortune

Ron Rosenbaum is one of the great masters of the metaphysical detective story, a nonfiction writer in the spirit of Borges, Nabokov and Poe. —Errol Morris (director of The Fog of War)

Few journalists inspire the kind of cult following that Rosenbaum has —Scott McLemee Newsday

I plan on hanging Ron Rosenbaum’s ‘marriage proposal’ [column] in a prominent place. Should my husband begin to take me for granted, he will be reminded that I am not without options. —Rosanne Cash

You made me look like a f_____g lunatic. —Oliver Stone

ALSO AVAILABLE (an anthology of others’ work): Those Who Forget the Past: The Question of Anti-Semitism

Bi-weekly Spectator columnist at Slate

"A Short Course in Intellectual Self-Defense"

I think I’ve found the solution for the (thankfully few) who attempt to post abusive, bigoted or sadly witless comments on this blog and haven’t read my repeated posts about my comments policy.

It’s a book called A Short Course in Intellectual Self-Defense. It’s by Normand Baillargeon, a professor at the University of Quebec and is available from Seven Stories Press, translated from the French by Andrea Schmidt.

Many would-be commenters on this and other blogs—and indeed many bloggers would profit from it. I know I have. It’s about how—and how not—to make arguments. I was particularly drawn to his “Rules of Argumentative Decorum” which I will try to use as a guide in moderating comments. Particularly Rule 4 which is the one most often violated by the abusive commenters:

Rule Four states: “You can only defend a thesis with arguments that are related to it.”

This basically rules out those who are intellectually incapable of addressing a subject without employing childish insults. Oh, I guess I need to explain “ad hominem” to these people. It means you don’t address the argument or the opinion, but instead resort to attacking the person making the argument. Usually because they are unable to mount a substantive defense of their opinion, or it’s based on factual (or general) ignorance. I suggest those whose comments aren’t posted get yourself a copy of Prof. B’s book and it will help you on an exciting voyage of self discovery.

Write the first comment

Comments have been archived for this page.

October 2007

"A Short Course in Intellectual Self-Defense"

Write the first comment

Pajamas Media

RSS Feeds